Do you have hair that’s not quite fine, but not super thick either? You’re in the medium thick hair club, and finding a hair tie that actually works can feel like a constant battle. The regular ones are too weak and snap, while the ones for thick hair are often too bulky and leave a dent. It’s frustrating when your ponytail starts to sag just an hour into the day.
The challenge is real. You need a tie with enough strength to handle your hair’s volume without being so tight it causes headaches or breakage. Many ties either lack the grip to hold your style or they pull and snag, damaging your hair every time you take them out. It’s not just about holding a ponytail; it’s about finding a comfortable, reliable solution that respects your hair’s health.
Thankfully, you don’t have to guess anymore. We’ve done the research and testing to find the best hair ties specifically for medium thick hair. This review breaks down the top performers, comparing their hold, comfort, and value so you can easily find your perfect match and finally end the struggle.
| Product Image | Product Name | Best For | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Goody Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Hair Elastics | Maximum Strength Hold | Prices |
 |
Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties No Damage | Smooth No-Damage Hold | Prices |
 |
GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands | Curly and Textured Hair | Prices |
 |
100PCS Black Hair Ties for Women Girls | Best Budget Bulk Pack | Prices |
Goody Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Hair Elastics
If you have medium to thick hair and are tired of hair ties that snap, slip, or leave a dent, these Goody Ouchless elastics are the perfect solution for you.
The “Ouchless” feature is a game-changer because the fabric-wrapped elastic has no metal parts. This means you can pull your hair up without it snagging or pulling out strands. The “Extra Thick” design provides a stronger hold, so your ponytail stays put all day without needing constant re-adjustment. For example, they can easily handle a high, bouncy ponytail during a workout without losing their grip.
Beyond being gentle and strong, these elastics are surprisingly durable. They don’t lose their stretch after multiple uses, and the fabric coating prevents them from fraying or breaking easily. This combination of comfort, hold, and longevity makes them a fantastic value and a reliable everyday hair essential.
Pros:
- Truly snag-free and gentle on hair
- Excellent, secure hold for thicker hair types
- No metal parts to break or rust
- Durable and long-lasting stretch
- Comes in a multi-pack with various colors
Cons:
- Can be a bit difficult to remove without stretching out
- May be too thick for very fine or short hair
- The fabric can sometimes get caught on rough surfaces
My Honest Opinion:
For anyone with medium or thick hair, these hair ties are absolutely worth the investment. They solve the core problems of breakage and slippage, making them a staple you’ll be glad to have in your drawer.
Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties No Damage
If you have medium to thick hair and are tired of ties that cause breakage or leave a crease, these Kitsch nylon hair ties are the perfect solution for you.
These ties are made from a soft, stretchy nylon that feels gentle on your hair. Unlike traditional elastics, they don’t have a harsh metal clasp or a tight, binding seam. This means you can wear your ponytail all day without getting that dreaded headache, and when you take it out, your hair is smooth and crease-free.
Beyond being damage-free, they are surprisingly durable and come in a huge variety of colors and patterns. You can find a set to match any outfit or mood. They hold thick hair securely without slipping, making them both a practical and stylish choice for everyday use.
Pros:
- Gentle on hair and prevents breakage
- No crease or headache after wearing
- Holds thick hair securely without slipping
- Wide variety of fun colors and patterns
- Durable and long-lasting
Cons:
- Can be difficult to find in stores
- May lose elasticity over time if over-stretched
- Not as strong for very high, tight hairstyles
My Honest Opinion:
For anyone with medium or thick hair looking for a comfortable, daily-wear hair tie that protects their hair, this is absolutely worth the investment. They are a simple upgrade that makes a noticeable difference.
GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands
If you have thick hair that snaps regular hair ties, these GIMME Beauty bands are the perfect solution you’ve been waiting for.
The key is the “extra stretch” material. It expands easily to wrap around thick ponytails and buns multiple times without pulling or snagging. You get a secure hold that actually feels comfortable, not tight and headache-inducing. For example, you can twist it three times for a high ponytail that stays put during a workout, and it won’t leave a massive dent when you take it out.
Beyond the stretch, these bands are surprisingly durable. They resist snapping and don’t lose their elasticity quickly, even with daily use. The seamless, snag-free design also means you can confidently use them on wet hair or delicate styles without causing breakage. It’s a small upgrade that makes a huge difference in your daily routine.
Pros:
- Excellent stretch accommodates very thick hair easily
- Secure hold without causing headaches or pulling
- Minimizes creases and dents in your hair
- Durable construction that resists snapping
- Snag-free design is gentle on all hair types
Cons:
- More expensive than basic drugstore hair ties
- The fabric can sometimes collect lint
My Honest Opinion:
For anyone with thick, hard-to-manage hair, these are absolutely worth the investment. They solve the core problems of breakage and discomfort, making them a staple you’ll be glad you bought.
100PCS Black Hair Ties for Women Girls
If you’re looking for a simple, affordable, and reliable hair tie for everyday use on medium to thick hair, this 100-pack of black elastics is your perfect match.
These hair ties are incredibly gentle, thanks to their seamless, no-damage design. They don’t snag or pull, so you can put your hair up and take it down multiple times a day without worrying about breakage. This makes them ideal for everything from a quick ponytail during a workout to a messy bun while working from home.
You get a massive 100-count in one bag, which means you’ll always have a spare. The classic black color is versatile and discreet, blending in with most hair colors. While they are strong, they don’t feel tight or leave a harsh crease, offering a comfortable hold that’s just right for daily styles.
Pros:
- Extremely gentle and snag-free
- Huge value with 100 pieces per pack
- Comfortable hold without being too tight
- Simple, versatile black color
Cons:
- Not suitable for very heavy or long thick hair
- Elasticity may lessen over many months
My Honest Opinion:
For the price, this is an unbeatable basic. Anyone who goes through hair ties quickly should buy this pack; it solves the “lost hair tie” problem for months.
Buyer’s Guide: 3 Key Factors to Consider
Durability and Stretch
For medium-thick hair, a hair tie’s ability to maintain its elasticity is non-negotiable. Look for bands specifically labeled “extra thick” or “extra stretch.” A good test is to stretch the tie a few times; if it immediately feels loose or doesn’t snap back, it will quickly become useless in your hair.
Gentleness on Hair
Avoiding breakage and creases is a top priority. Ties made from seamless, soft fabrics like nylon or a smooth, knit cotton are your best bet. Steer clear of any elastics with metal parts or rough, exposed stitching that can snag and damage your strands.
Hold Without the Headache
The goal is a secure hold that doesn’t cause pain. Wider, flatter bands often distribute pressure more evenly than thin, string-like ties. If you frequently get headaches from high ponytails, a gentler, more flexible material will make a world of difference.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: How can I prevent hair ties from leaving a crease in my hair?
A1: To prevent creases, opt for seamless, spiral-style ties (like the Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties) or soft, fabric-covered bands without metal parts. Also, try not to place your ponytail in the exact same spot every day and avoid using brand new, super-tight elastics on dry hair.
Q2: What is the best type of hair tie for a thick, high ponytail that stays put?
A2: For a secure, high ponytail on thick hair, the Goody Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Hair Elastics are a top choice. Their robust construction and strong hold are designed specifically for thicker hair types without the same level of pulling as thinner bands.
Q3: Are there hair ties that are truly gentle enough for fine, breakage-prone hair?
A3: Yes, the Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties No Damage are excellent for fine, fragile hair. Their smooth, seamless nylon construction glides in and out of hair without snagging, making them one of the gentlest options available.
Q4: Is it worth spending more on a pack of hair ties?
A4: It can be. Higher-priced options like GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands often use premium materials that are gentler, more durable, and retain their shape longer. However, a large, affordable pack like the 100PCS Black Hair Ties is great for stocking up, despite a potential trade-off in longevity.
Q5: Why do my hair ties always seem to snap or lose elasticity?
A5: This is often due to the material quality. Natural rubber can dry out and degrade. Ties made with synthetic blends or coated elastics, like the GIMME Beauty bands, tend to have a longer lifespan and better stretch recovery.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
Our top pick for most with medium-thick hair is the Goody Ouchless XL & Extra Thick Hair Elastics for their unbeatable, secure hold. If your priority is preventing damage and creases, choose the Kitsch Nylon Hair Ties No Damage. For the best blend of gentle stretch and durability, the GIMME Beauty Thick Hair Extra Stretch Bands are excellent. If you need a massive, budget-friendly supply, the 100PCS Black Hair Ties for Women Girls will get the job done.
